Back to Main forum index
Back to Current forum index

AuthorTopic: Amino Acid Solutions
speedy
08-16-2001
03:06 AM
Wai had recommended supplementing with some Amino Acid liquids, however, she admonished me to stay away from products like the Bragg's Liquid Aminos as they contain loads of sodium. I went into the local health food store today and picked up a bottle of Amino Acids from a company called Solgar. In comparing it to the others they had, it seemed to have the least amount of 'other ingredients' on it. I am slightly hesitant to try it since I don't know if any of these ingredients will cause breakouts. Therefore, I will list them here for you guys to read:

It is called "Liquid: Predigested Collagen - Protein" by Solgar.

The ingredients are: Soluble Protein Hydrolysate, Deionized Water, Sorbitol Solution, Citric Acid, Natural Cherry Flavor, Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Benzoate.

Each two tablespoon serving provide:

L-Alanine 1300mg
L-Arginine 1200mg
L-Aspartic Acid 900mg
L-Cystine 10mg
L-Glutamic Acid 1500mg
Glycine 3500mg
L-Histidine 110mg
L-Hydroxlysine 150mg
L-Hydroxproline 1000mg
L-Isoleucine 200mg
L-Leucine 450mg
L-Lysine 650mg
L-Methionine 110mg
L-Phenylalanine 35mg
L-Proline 2300mg
L-Serine 1000mg
L-Threonine 300mg
L-Tyrosine 100mg
L-Valine 350mg

Calories: 95
Protein: 15g
Carbohydrates: 9g
Cholesterol: 0g
Fat: 0g

It also has a warning about the fact it contains Phenylketonurics(PKU) since it has L-Phenylalnine. (What is bad about these anyhow?)

Since I know hardly anything about Amino Acid supplementation, it would be helpful if someone could let me know if this product is worth taking or if I should return it to the store and try to find something else.

Thanks guys!
Seth

Wai
08-16-2001
06:27 AM
No, I'm sorry, this one is of no use, because the protein is 'dirty' protein.

Protein is amino acids linked to each other. What you need are single amino acids; free amino acids. And because they are acids, they never remain free under normal circumstances; they easily react upon eachother, so that is why real free ammin aids come in an acidic liquid that can only been maintained in glass tubes. they are completely glass, but you can break them at the top, (mostly) breaking without any small pieces braking off.

If the amino acids do not come in a liquid that needs to be maintained in glass tubes, they are notfe amino acids, but 'dirty' protein.

If you find such amino acids (I remember from my experiment that they came in orange boxes; I still need to go back to that fitness-shop where they sell them), please first only take a leaflet where the amino acid contents ar itd, so that I can check with you whether it supplies you with sufficient of all the essential ones, okay?

Wai
08-16-2001
06:35 AM
quote:
Seth wrote
It also has a warning about the fact it contains Phenylketonurics(PKU) since it has L-Phenylalnine. (What is bad about these anyhow?)

I believe it is a rare medical condition in which people have problems metabolizing excessive phenylalanine. Such people can only eat foods that are relatively low in phenylalanine.
Phenylalanine is a regular essential amino acid almost all foods contain.
A number of amino acids can be converted in sugar-like molecules or fat-like molecules (=keton bodies). I guess in this disorder consuming much phenylalanine causes the accumulation of the keton body originated from phenylalanine.

onetwothree
08-20-2001
06:20 PM
Hi,

I'm looking for the right amino acid supplement as well since I am extremely active and am looking to increase my lean body mass by a significant amount. Searching on the web I haven't been able to find liquid free amino acids. Here are some links to what I have been able to find :

Gematria on free aminos

One of their products I was thinking of.
The 500mg/$50 better be a typo!

Individual ones in tablets and capsules :
Individual ones in tablets and capsules

More individual ones

Don't know much about this one

If I were to take them in capsule or tablet form I assume I would try to take them in ratios similiar to eggs? The price does not really bother me much. These links seem to be lacking in info a bit. Any ideas on what I should ask them?

Has anyone else found any links?

Thanks,
Rob

Wai
08-21-2001
02:57 AM
123,

Any other protein / amino acid supplement than liquid free amino acids can very easily cause new pimples, while liquid free amino acids do not at all.
so I advice you to search on for lquid free amino acids. They are there. Look for them in the bodybuilder sections.

Wai
08-21-2001
03:32 AM
123,

Once your skin is clear you can try these free (?) amino acids to test whether they cause acne in you or not.

First you only need:
L-methionine
L-cysteine

This because fruits already contain very much of all the other amino acids.
Not until you would take more than 1,000 mg of cysteine and methione daily, you would need to start supplementing with phenylalanine and tyrosine too.
Taking 1,000 mg cysteine and methionine this would already double the protein quality of the protein in 6 kg fruits (over 13 pounds; 1% protein in average fruits).
So, this 6 kg of fruit (including a handful of Brazil nuts, 100 gram dried dates and 100 gram dired figs; 10 gram protein in total) that contains about 67 gram protein, with a protein quality that equals that of soy-protein, now supplies you with as many valuable amino acids to build muscles as 134 gram soy protein!!!

Supplementing over 1,000 methionine and cystein, you would need equally much extra phenylalanine and tyrosine (so equally much minus 1,000 mg):

for example:
taking 3,000 methionine and cysteine, you would need 2,000 mg phenylalanine and tyrosine.
But you better start with 500 or 1,000 mg methionine and cysteine first.

Instead of 500 mg methionine and 500 mg cystein, you can aslo take 1,000 mg methionine only, since the body can easily convert methionine into cystein (not the other way around) according to its needs.

Instead of 500 mg phenyalanine and 500 mg tyrosine, you can also take 1,000 mg phenylalanine, since the body can convert phenylalanine into tyrosine easily (not the other way around).


So, summarizing, if you want to try them, you first only need methionine, and once you want to supplement more than 2,000 mg methionine a day, you would need equally much phenylalanine as the methionine consumed on top of the 2,000 mg.

But again, they may very well cause acne if they are not really free.

PS, if you want to learn more about protein quality and the amino acids in fruits, see http://www.18.WaiSays.com

[ August 21, 2001: Message edited by: Wai ]

Wai
08-21-2001
08:13 AM
I totally forgot about egg yolks and fish...
In egg yolks and fish methionine and cysteine are also the scarsest amino acids (relative to our needs for those individual amino acids), but here the proportions are are bit more even;
If you consume 100 gram egg yolks (5) or fish, then upt to 500 mg methionine solely makes very much sense, increasing the protein quality with about 50%, thus making the 11 gram protein in the egg yolks as valuable as 16 gram protein or the 21 gram protein in tuna as valuable as 30 gram protein.
The extra 5 gram egg yolk protein is equivalent to 8 gram soy protein, and the extra 10 gram tuna protein is equivalent 13 gram soy protein.

So here the results are less spectacular than in fruit, but this gain (8 to 13 gram "soy" protein extra) is on top of the results in fruit protein. (67 gram "soy" protein extra)

So a total daily supplementation of 2,500 mg methionine will increase the overall protein quality to such an extend that it's effect has the equivalent of 72 to 77 gram additional "soy" protein.
Maybe this one from Solgar is a good try?
Or this one of Solaray, that you had already found ($5.59)
Or this one from Twin Lab ($5.09)($4.62 at Nourishingfoods.com)

Of course you should open the capsules and not take the capsule itself. Best consumed with the fruits.

Please keep us updated about the results of this experiment!!!


If you want to supplement over 2,500 mg methionine, than you need to supplement with additional equal amounts of phenylalanine and methionine (and other ones the more you go up).

[ August 21, 2001: Message edited by: Wai ]

speedy
08-21-2001
11:18 PM
Thanks Wai...

The supplement I got from Solgar is different (as I posted all the contents on the first post on this thread.) I will see what I can find. So you are suggesting that taking anything under 2500mgs of Methionine is good enough? I don't really need all those other amino acids? And does it have to be liquid or are caps ok?

Wai
08-22-2001
10:47 AM
What you need are liquid free amino acids. The capsules contain liquids and they are free amino acids, so in theory that should be the right ones...
but you never know what they really put in there...

Consuming kilos of fruits (what we all do) we absorb about 30 to 65 gram protein from all these fruits in total (depending on your energy requirements)
These protein contain all required amino acids, but they are relatively low in methionine and cysteine, compared to all other amino acids, when compared to how much you need of every amino acid.
By supplementing with methionine you also fulfil your need for cysteine. And not until you supplement over 2,500 mg methionine, other amino acids need to be supplemented too (phenylalanine / tyrosine)

This means that when you eat so much fruits, you can very easily increase their protein quality by taking methionine only, because they are only very low in methionine.

If you would ingest much high quality protein from escargot for example (then you would not need extra protein, but anyway), then you would need to supplement with many different amino acids to increase its protein quality a bit.

so, that is the good thing about the combination fruits and single amino acids; you can very easily increase fruit-protein quality by taking only one: methionine.

Please take a look at http://www.18.waisays.com
there you see the amounts of essential amino acids listed in 2kg, 4kg and 6kg fruits respectively (at the left) and the required amounts of amino acids (at the right). From this you can clearly see that all amino acids are abundantly present, except for methionine / cysteine.

The caps should be okay because they are supposed to contain liquid free amino acids...
Anything up to 2,500 mg methionine is perfect, yes!
If you would need more protein (or if you would not eat so much fruits), then you would need other amino acids too.