Back to Main forum index
Back to Current forum index

AuthorTopic: Am I freakishly skinny?
Roy
03-17-2003
12:56 AM
My whole life ive always been skinny, and recently everyones making such a big deal about it since i became a fruitarian. Im 15, and i remember that I was skinny even when I used to eat out at fast food! I think i have a very fast matabolism (whatever that is). Its the only way i can explain it. My doctor says my Body mass index is off the charts, and im in the "danger zone" but i find this hard to believe. Im 6 foot 1, and i weigh about 115 lbs on average. Is this dangerously skinny. I must admit, that i do look very thin!!! But i do eat when im hungry, because this seems natural.
mengyao
03-17-2003
04:24 PM
i dont have any answer for you, but all i gotta say is consider yourself SUPER lucky that you stay that skinny. [Eek!] at least you dont have to worry about overeating on "non raw" foods. at least you get to pick between being skinny, or gaining weight (thats also easy to do) [Embarrassed]
risrosen
03-18-2003
08:19 AM
I beg to differ, Yuna. Those of us who are chronically underweight don't get to pick between being skinny and gaining weight. It's just as hard, if not harder, for us to gain weight as it is for others to lose it. Neither do most of us consider ourselves fortunate to be this way. Not the men, certainly.
risrosen
03-18-2003
08:45 AM
Roy, based on my experience of being skinny I would say you're pretty thin! I'm 6'2" and before my eating disorder started I weighed about 150 and was considered pretty skinny. Since the eating problems started, my weight has fluctuated between 125 and 145, being around 135 a lot of the time but I've spent a lot of time weighing 130 or so. And people considered me very underweight. Once I got down to 120 and there was much concern!
Wai
03-20-2003
01:14 PM
Roy, you are thin, but you are in puberty; you're supposed to be skinny at that age...
You may be off the charts, but that doesn't necessarily mean you are not healthy.

To increase your weight, you need to focus on high caloric, low fiber foods.
the easiest way to increase your bodyweight on this diet, is the RRM way, with consuming as much egg yolks and/or fish as your skin can cope with
risrosen
03-20-2003
03:06 PM
Mea culpa. Sorry for shooting my mouth off there, Roy.
Isis
03-22-2003
12:26 PM
quote:
Originally posted by yuna:
i dont have any answer for you, but all i gotta say is consider yourself SUPER lucky that you stay that skinny. [Eek!] at least you dont have to worry about overeating on "non raw" foods. at least you get to pick between being skinny, or gaining weight (thats also easy to do) [Embarrassed]

Now thats the type of response I used to HATE with a passion. I was PAINFULLY skinny/scrawny for most of my life. As a kid, at first all the jibes came from my family (all skinny as well, but not as bad as I was) and they would say such things as "your hip bones are jutting out" or "your waist is soooo tiny, I can wrap my hand around it". It didnt hurt too much cus I was a kid, but when I became a teenager, it wasnt just family, it was my mates and worse...boys! I was so upset when on curvy girl came up to me and asked "Your sister has got a good figure, nice hips and boobs, when are you going to be like her?" I promised her that in two years (when I would be around the same age as my sister then) that I would have more curves.

Believe it or not but two years later she came back to ask me why I had failed to 'develop'. The guys started commenting on how skinny I was etc. Looking back now, it's no wonder, cus I used to eat mostly fruits and peanuts (plus normal cooked meals, but MOSTLY fruits). So despite having a growth spurt and developing breasts, my own YOUNGER sister had the nerve to comment one day "your boobs must be from the other side of the family" cus hers where at least twice the size of mine.

In all this time I had tried desperately to gain weight. I got so obsessed I used to WATCH overweight people and eat what they eat and do what they did. I quickly found FOUR HUGE friends and copied their lifestyle to a T. They would take me out eating huge portions of fatty foods etc. They never seemed to stop eating or thinking about food or planning what next to eat and I learned to tolerate it and eat just as much. I would force myself to sleep for hours at a time during the day/evening (cus the less active you are, the more likely you are to gain weight). I got so desperate that I even started GUZZLING pure oil from the cooking bottle and I begged my mother to give me the fat she cuts off from meat. Much later I got a body building magazine and started eating like a body builder etc. I would stay much later after everyone had left the dinner table and FORCE myself to keep eating (normally I would only manage half a portion of certian high carbohydrate dinners, but as I had heard that they could make me gain weight, I would continue to struggle to polish the plate). I ate peanuts/boiled sweets/fatty pastries etc by the bucket.

Two years after all this and I was still a rake. I hated my sister for being so effortlessly curvy and I resented people (family, friends, strangers...even enemies!) commenting on the difference etc. So one day I went to a pharmacy and asked the woman there if there were any drugs that could make me gain weight. I hate to admit this, but I bought these VERY expensive tablets and proceeded to take them for months (it took all my pocket money and then some). It was a dangerous thing to do, because I did not tell anyone what I was taking.

Sure enough, within six months I had gained about three stone in weight. For the first time I actually had a curvy bottom and the guys responded with wolf whistles etc. The girls became green with envy etc. Till this day I have maintained the curves and in a way I wish I don't have them anymore. I have never been able to deal with the amount of male attention that they draw (I can't tell you how many times I have been stalked). The most scary thing about it is that if I should gain a stone now, most of it will go to my boobs! You should see me when I'm ovulating. yeesh. I was recently on steroids and I gained about 3 kg. I cannot describe the amount of attention I got from men. Even my boss wanted to cup a feel of my rear! One day it was so bad (bearing in mind that I was fairly sick/weak) I had to come out of a train at an earlier stop and get a cab home (costing me an arm and a leg) because every where I went guys kept hitting on me! I think I must have been bursting out of my clothes, I could not handle it at all and when I came off the steroids and lost the weight, I was estatic.

So I'm curvy, not skinny, just curvy. And it took years to get to this weight. I have maintained it for over ten years now, but maybe if I could I would go back to how I used to be, because I really hate having men drool all over me. I don't think I am beautiful, but what man can resist luscious curves? (think Jennifer Lopez's 'asset').

I'm sorry I have written soooo much here, but I hate those comments about how 'lucky' one is to be so skinny etc. I still get envious and downright nasty looks from women who consider me 'skinny', even though I am not. Comments like that are not helping. You have no idea how HARD it is for some naturally underweight people to gain weight [Mad] ...and I'm a woman, I'm supposed to have all these hormones to aid that etc. Yet we have here a teenage guy who is probably getting ribbed by his mates and ignored by the girls. My heart goes out to him.

Okay I'll stop now.
[Frown]
JustinCredible
03-25-2003
06:21 AM
For me it sounds very unnaturally - woman displeased with low weight. The thiner - the better, I always thought - dont strike me on the head its only my look on beauty. I can understand some low-weigthed men, including myself, in their attitude to gain some bioweight. For me neither sports nor eating helps. The thing I started trying now is training by Mentcer principles - may be that would be of use.
Isis
03-27-2003
04:37 PM
ALL the men I know prefer women with a bit of meat on them. It's only 'women' who fancy lollipop ladies (stick body, massive head...think that actress from Bridget Jones' Diary). It gets really sad when they delibrately starve themselves etc. to maintain an obviously sickly state (theres a big difference between being naturally skinny the way nature intended, and forcing oneself to be so skinny that nature rebels against it)

And yes, although in the minority who are virtually unheard of (because no one takes their problem as 'real') there are women out there who are so skinny that they are displeased with their lack of a feminine figure or stamina. Calista Flockhart (Ally McBeal, forive my spelling) is like a teenage BOY and there is no man on earth I know who admits to fancying her (apart from wrinkley old lech Harrison Ford [Wink] hehehe only kidding!) but I suppose she "thinks" she's drop dead gorgeous. hehehehe [Big Grin]

I'm not saying severely skinny women are ugly, just that they don't look like 'women' but teenage boys...if they are flatchested enough any way [Wink] .

By the way, I think being on this acne diet is causing my body to return to those days, cus I am still losing weight and finding it difficult to do anything about it (it gets harder and harder to keep reminding myself to eat etc. when I have other pressing things to do/sort out at work/home).

Please open your mind. Women like me do exist.

(By the way, my boyfriend is sooo skinny that he's developed lanugo!!!!! [Eek!] He tries sooooo hard to gain weight but ALWAYS forgets to eat, sometimes for days! I actually hate it cus his bones poke my body and it hurts to give him a bearhug, but who am I to complain?)

[Cool]
JustinCredible
03-31-2003
03:42 AM
I'm not saying severely skinny women are ugly, just that they don't look like 'women' but teenage boys...

The one and ONLY thing to make woman look like a teenage boy is a short haircut. No body conditions (fat skinny or other) are able to make a human being ugly, except the face.
Isis
04-01-2003
12:17 PM
quote:
Originally posted by JustinCredible:
The one and ONLY thing to make woman look like a teenage boy is a short haircut. No body conditions (fat skinny or other) are able to make a human being ugly, except the face.

I beg to differ.

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. There are sayings like "Nice body, shame about the face" AS WELL AS sayings like "Nice face, shame about the body" (especially regarding obese women, and no...it's not fair, but it's something I hear men say all the time).

These days a lot of teenage boys are into grunge etc. with long flowing (and usually matted unwashed) hair. You see them in their baggy clothes, with their pants almost down to their knees etc. The funny thing is...sometimes there's a girl in the group and you won't be able to tell!

[Big Grin]